Comparative Negligence in Car Accidents on Long Island

Comparative Negligence in Car Accidents on LI

If you’ve been involved in a car accident on Long Island, you’ll know how stressful and overwhelming the experience can be. One of the most critical factors in determining your legal rights and potential compensation is understanding the concept of comparative negligence. In the United States, the legal system operates under a fault-based system, wherein the at-fault driver is held responsible for the accident’s damages. Comparative negligence is a crucial legal principle that affects how fault is allocated in multiple-party car accident cases.

Key Takeaways:

  • Comparative negligence is an essential legal principle that impacts car accident cases in the United States.
  • The US legal system operates under a fault-based system, wherein the at-fault driver is held responsible for damages.
  • Understanding comparative negligence can be critical in determining legal rights and potential compensation for car accident victims.
  • Comparative negligence involves apportioning liability among multiple parties in a car accident case.
  • Evidence and contributing factors such as driver behavior and road conditions are essential in establishing comparative negligence in a car accident case.

Auto accident involving two cars

What is Comparative Negligence?

Comparative negligence is a legal principle that helps to determine the extent to which each party in a car accident is responsible for the resulting damages. Under this principle, the court will apportion liability based on the degree of fault of each party.

The Negligence Principle

The negligence principle is the foundation of comparative negligence. This principle holds that each person has a legal responsibility to behave reasonably and avoid actions or omissions that could harm others. It is the legal duty of drivers to obey traffic rules, avoid distractions, and stay alert while driving.

Apportioning Liability

Apportioning liability means that each party’s degree of fault is determined and used to calculate the damages they are responsible for. For example, suppose a driver exceeds the speed limit and collides with another vehicle whose driver made an improper turn. In that case, the court may apportion liability as 80% to the speeding driver and 20% to the driver making the improper turn (hypothetical example).

Legal Responsibility

Each party involved in a car accident is legally responsible for taking reasonable steps to prevent accidents and avoid harm to others. This responsibility extends to both drivers and passengers. Any actions or omissions that contribute to the accident can be considered a breach of that responsibility and may result in legal liability.

How Does Comparative Negligence Impact Car Accident Claims on Long Island?

Understanding the concept of comparative negligence is crucial in determining liability and compensation in car accident claims. In a comparative negligence system, fault is apportioned among the parties involved and compensation is awarded based on each party’s degree of fault.

This means that even if you were partially at fault for a car accident, you may still be entitled to compensation. However, the amount of compensation will be reduced in proportion to your degree of fault.

Comparative Fault

Comparative fault refers to the percentage of fault that each party bears in a car accident. It is determined by evaluating each party’s actions leading up to the accident and how they contributed to the incident. For example, if you were found to be 30% at fault for a car accident, you would be responsible for paying 30% of the damages, and the other party would be responsible for the remaining 70%.

Comparative fault is used in New York State, and depending on where your accident occurred, New York laws may apply, or laws from another jurisdiction. Our attorneys can help you determine what laws apply to your case.

It is important to note that some states have modified comparative negligence laws, which may limit or bar recovery if you were more than 50% at fault for the accident. Others may use contributory negligence, and may completely bar you from a claim if you are even slightly at fault. Again, consulting with our experienced car accident lawyers can help you understand the laws applicable to your accident.

Establishing Negligence in a Car Accident Case

Proving negligence is crucial in winning a car accident claim. To establish comparative negligence in a car accident case, you need to gather evidence that shows the contributing factors that led to the accident. The negligence law can be complex, so it’s essential to have a knowledgeable legal professional guide you through the process.

Contributing Factors

Several factors can contribute to establishing comparative negligence in a car accident case. These can include:

  • Driver behavior: Evidence of reckless or careless driving by one or more parties can help prove negligence.
  • Road conditions: Poor road conditions, such as a lack of signage or slippery roads, can also contribute to an accident.
  • Weather conditions: Adverse weather conditions, such as heavy rain or snow, can affect visibility and control, leading to an accident.
  • Vehicle defects: Mechanical issues with a vehicle, such as malfunctioning brakes or tires, can also contribute to an accident.
  • Potential witness testimony: Witnesses who saw the accident happen can provide valuable testimony to support your claim.

Identification Numbers, various laboratory tests forensic equipment, conceptual image


To effectively prove comparative negligence, you need to gather strong evidence to support your claim. This can include:

    • Police reports: Police reports detailing the accident can provide valuable evidence to support your claim.
    • Photographs and Video: Pictures of the accident scene, including vehicle damage and road conditions, can support your claim.

Medical records: Medical records detailing any injuries sustained in the accident can help prove the severity of the incident.

  • Expert analysis: Expert analysis, such as accident reconstruction or vehicle inspections, can help establish the contributing factors of the accident.

Establishing negligence in a car accident case can be a complicated process. Having one of our skilled personal injury lawyers on your side can help ensure that all contributing factors and evidence are presented effectively in court, maximizing the chances of a successful claim.

How Can Lawyers Help with Comparative Negligence Claims?

Often times, parties will disagree on who is at fault. Your attorney will work hard to present evidence establishing that the other party bears all or some of the responsibility for your accident and injuries.

When navigating the complexities of the fault-based system in car accident claims, seeking the right legal representation is crucial. Our lawyers can provide valuable assistance throughout the entire process, from investigating the incident to negotiating a fair settlement.

Experience and Knowledge of Your Lawyers

One of the main benefits of hiring a knowledgeable lawyer for your comparative negligence claim is their experience in the field. A skilled lawyer will have a thorough understanding of the negligence law. They can use their knowledge to build a strong case on your behalf and maximize your chances of receiving fair compensation.

Assistance with Investigations

Lawyers also have the resources and connections to conduct thorough investigations into the incident. They can gather evidence and speak to witnesses to determine the contributing factors and establish liability. This is especially important in cases where multiple parties are involved, as apportioning liability can be complex and require extensive analysis.

Negotiating a Fair Settlement

Finally, lawyers can help negotiate a settlement that is fair and just for all parties involved. They can use their legal skills to advocate for your rights and ensure that you receive the compensation you are entitled to. Lawyers can also provide valuable advice and guidance on whether to accept a settlement offer or pursue the case in court.

Contact Law Office of Frank J. Cassisi, P.C. to Discuss Your Case

Now that you have a better understanding of comparative negligence and its implications in car accident claims, it is important to remember the crucial role that negligence law plays. Whether you are seeking compensation or defending against a claim, understanding the principles of comparative negligence can significantly impact the outcome of your case. Call Law Office of Frank J. Cassisi, P.C. today at (516) 294 5050 to discuss your case.


What is comparative negligence?

Comparative negligence is a legal concept that apportions liability in cases where multiple parties are involved in a car accident. It recognizes that more than one party may be at fault and assigns a percentage of responsibility to each party based on their degree of negligence.

How does comparative negligence impact car accident claims?

Comparative negligence affects car accident claims by determining the amount of compensation that each party is entitled to receive. The percentage of fault assigned to each party directly influences the final settlement amount or court award. If you are found to be partially responsible for the accident, your compensation may be reduced accordingly.

How is comparative negligence established in a car accident case?

Establishing comparative negligence in a car accident case involves presenting evidence that demonstrates the negligence of all parties involved. Factors such as driver behavior, road conditions, and witness testimony are considered in determining the percentage of fault assigned to each party. It is essential to gather strong evidence to support your claim and establish the degree of negligence.

How can our lawyers help with comparative negligence claims?

Our attorneys can provide valuable assistance with comparative negligence claims by providing legal representation and guidance throughout the process. They have a deep understanding of the negligence law and the fault-based system, enabling them to navigate complex legal procedures and ensure your rights are protected. Seeking legal representation can greatly increase your chances of obtaining fair compensation.

"*" indicates required fields

Contact Us
For a Free Consultation

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Scroll to Top