Has an accident in New York left you or a loved one injured? Choosing the right personal injury lawyer in NYC involves more than just finding someone who can represent your rights. New York has complex laws that may apply differently to a particular situation, timeline, or precedent.
In this guide, the Law Office of Frank J. Cassisi, P.C., explains the process of hiring the right injury attorney in New York. Evaluating the professional’s experience, track record, and communication style can streamline the decision.
Experience and Track Record Matter in Personal Injury Cases
According to NYC Department of Health data, the leading causes of unintentional injury deaths in New York from 2017 to 2019 were poisonings, falls, and vehicle collisions. For injury-related hospitalizations, falls topped the records during this same period.
With such a variety of personal injury cases needing representation, your attorney should be able to demonstrate an understanding of New York-specific laws and procedures. For example, the state’s comparative negligence rules may create unique challenges.
Before hiring any personal injury attorney in New York, you might also consider their experience in handling cases similar to your own. If you’ve had a vehicle accident, a lawyer who regularly represents car accident cases will bring different skills to the table than one who focuses primarily on medical malpractice. They’ll also understand no-fault insurance requirements better than someone who only handles premises liability.
Understanding Fee Structures When Hiring the Right Injury Attorney
The typical personal injury law firm in New York will work on a contingency fee basis, but this isn’t a given. A contingency arrangement could allow you to make a claim or file a lawsuit without paying the attorney any upfront legal costs. However, it is important to understand what percentage the attorney will take and whether that percentage changes if your case goes to trial.
You’ll also want to ask about additional costs you might incur during your case. Court filing fees, expert witness fees, and investigation costs can add up quickly.
Finding the Right Personal Injury Lawyer in NYC Requires Evaluating Some Key Qualities
The New York City Comptroller’s Annual Claims Report for 2023 shows that the city paid $739.6 million in settled tort claims, which includes personal injury cases. Here is what matters in lawyer selection if you are going to navigate New York’s complex legal system and build your case:
- Strong communication skills
- Responsiveness to your calls and emails
- Transparent fee structures with no surprise charges
- Positive reviews from former clients and the legal community
- A willingness to take your case to trial rather than settle for too little
- Resources to investigate your case thoroughly and hire expert witnesses
New York law imposes strict deadlines for filing personal injury lawsuits. You generally have three years from the date of your injury to file a claim, but government entities have different notice requirements. An attorney who communicates clearly and keeps you informed throughout your case may streamline the process for you after an injury.
Understanding the personal injury statute of limitations in New York is also crucial. The right attorney will ensure that you don’t miss these important deadlines and can file your claims on time. They will also advise you when taking immediate action is necessary to preserve evidence and discuss your rights.
Some Final Personal Injury Attorney Tips
According to a 2025 report from Lawsuit Information Center data, New York has paid out far higher personal injury damages than the national median. The state has awarded over $287,600 versus a national median of just over $34,500. This is mainly attributed to the no-fault insurance payouts adequately covering smaller cases in New York, so only larger permanent injury cases show up in this median figure for the state.
If you’d like peace of mind, carefully consider the firm’s resources when choosing a personal injury lawyer in NYC. Your attorney needs to be able to adapt to the nuances of your case and how it fits into New York’s legal system. If they are handing over to a junior associate immediately after signing you up, how will they make time to focus on your day-to-day communication and case work?
You should also check whether the attorney has relationships with medical professionals, accident reconstruction experts, and other network contacts who could strengthen your case.
Work With the Law Office of Frank J. Cassisi, P.C., in New York
Navigating a legal case can be a stressful time in your life. If an attorney makes you feel rushed, dismissed, or pressured, those are red flags. The right lawyer will treat you with compassion while maintaining professional boundaries, setting realistic expectations about your case, and fully respecting your attorney-client relationship.
The Law Office of Frank J. Cassisi, P.C., brings a strong understanding of New York’s personal injury statute of limitations to help you understand your rights. If you need a personal injury lawyer in NYC, call us at 516-294-5050 to schedule a consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are answers to common questions about selecting legal representation for your personal injury case in New York.
How Long Does a Personal Injury Case Take in New York?
How long a personal injury case in New York takes depends on the injury severity and settlement negotiations. If a complex trial becomes necessary, it could take years.
What Should I Bring to My First Meeting With My Personal Injury Attorney in New York?
When you meet with your attorney, you should bring all accident-related documents, including:
- NYPD or other relevant police reports
- Medical records
- Insurance correspondence
- Photographs of injuries or accident scenes
It can also be helpful to have a list of questions you want to ask the attorney.
Can I Switch Lawyers if I’m Not Satisfied With My Current Attorney?
Yes, you can change to a different personal injury lawyer in NYC at any time. Review your fee agreement to understand any financial implications and ensure a smooth transition to new representation.
